Chapter 54

Josie POV

I sat there listening to the conversations happening around me. I had not jumped into the conversation. I had noticed Sam had not either. I kept playing in my mind the man who visited Sarah last night. Something about his description was taunting me. It was not possible. He was dead. Gone. We had burned his body.

“The man you are describing is my father,” I share with the group hurriedly. I cannot stop the words from forming and leaving my mouth. I saw Sam stand a little taller while everyone else simply stared. “Eric beat your father when he killed him. He could not be alive,” Jenna says with fear in her voice. It was no secret my father had been after her when he was alive.

“I know. I was there when Eric killed him. I simply cannot understand how it could be him. What other explanation is there?” I ask everyone in the room looking at Sam. He looks at me like he is pained for me. “Maybe it is someone else? Did your fa